The elephant in the courtroom isn’t Happy

Photo by Beks on Unsplash

Happy is an elephant in New York City’s Bronx Zoo. She was young in the 1970s in Thailand, which would make her middle-aged in human years. Happy is now a petitioner in possibly, the most important animal-rights case of the 21st century. The New York Court of Appeals will soon deliberate on her years of detention. Is it lawful? Should she be condemned to years of separation from her kin? Happy has lived for 15 years quite alone (and presumably unhappy). Experts say her situation could increase the risk of arthritis, depression and bone disease, among other things.

But Happy has no legally enforceable rights because she’s an elephant and not a legal person. The Nonhuman Rights Project, a civil rights association in the US, says that a subject’s species should be irrelevant in matters of legal rights.

They might have a point. After all, non-living entities such as idols, corporations and ships have legal personhood. So why not animals? Why not Happy?

There is precedent. Argentine courts have recognised the legal personhood of Cecilia the Chimpanzee. Ditto for Chuco the Bear in Columbia. A river has been granted legal personhood in New Zealand.

As Jill Lepore, an American historian and journalist writes in The Atlantic: “No case like this has ever reached so high a court, anywhere in the English-speaking world. This case isn’t about an elephant. It’s about the elephant in the courtroom: the place of the natural world in laws and constitutions written for humankind.”

Stay tuned.

Originally published at on November 17, 2021.




PhD. Journalism by trade & inclination. Sign up for free email updates on email me at

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

How Ted Bundy Help Catch a Serial Killer

Officials identified 10-year-old Landyn Waff who was injured after an auto-pedestrian crash in…

Forced Arbitration Roadblock: A Wrongful Credit Report Pull?

They Were Responsible for Killing Thousands of People and Never Went to Jail

Judicialization of politics, judicial activism, and institutional tensions

Get Back Whip Laws? Explained

Get Back Whip Laws? Explained

Police Recover Submerged Chevy Impala

Is it a Debt Collector or a Scammer?

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Rashmee Roshan Lall

Rashmee Roshan Lall

PhD. Journalism by trade & inclination. Sign up for free email updates on email me at

More from Medium

Analysis | Polexit? Don’t count on it.

Aerial view of Gdansk, Poland

Gas Wars: The Future of European Energy Security and the Fate of the Green Deal

Lessons in bridging the humanitarian, development and peace divide